Electrophysiological Tests in CF Diagnosis: Nasal Potential Difference is More Predictive than Sweat Test

Hana Goldstein 1 Yasmin Yaakov 1 Michael Cohen 1 Hannah Blau 2 Ori Efrati 3 Lea Bentur 4 Galit Livnat 5 Elie Picard 6 Micha Aviram 7 מיכאל וילשנסקי 1
1Pediatric Gastroenterology, CF Center, Hadassah Hebrew University Medical Center
2CF Center, Schneider Childrens Hospital
3CF Center, Safra Childrens Hospital
4CF Center, Ruth Childrens Hospital
5CF Center, Carmel Medical Center
6CF Center, Shaare Zedek Medical Center
7CF Center, Soroka Medical Center

Nasal Potential Difference (NPD) is one of the criteria for diagnosis of CF in questionable cases. The aim was to compare the diagnostic outcome of a cohort of patients with questionable CF phenotypes.

Methods: Patients with suspected CF performed sweat test and NPD.

Results: 449 patients underwent both NPD and sweat tests. 246 had sweat < 40, 33 had >60 and 170 had 40-60, 375 had normal NPD and 74 abnormal, 26 of 375 are in the CF registry. Of the 74 diagnosed as abnormal, 21 are in the CF registry; sensitivity of NPD is 44.7% and specificity 86.8% with negative predictive value of 93% This is better than the sweat test which has sensitivity of 45.4%, specificity of 58.1% and negative predictive value of 88.8%. There were 8 patients with a normal sweat test and abnormal NPD of which 5 are registered as CF. There were 83 patients with a positive sweat test and normal NPD of which 5 are in the CF registry; sensitivity of NPD is 50%, specificity is 96.2%, positive predictive value 62.5% and negative predictive value of 93.9%. Of the 170 patients with borderline sweat test, 5 out of 140 (3.6%) with normal NPD are in the registry while of the 31 patients with abnormal NPD, 7 (23%) are in the registry.

Conclusion: In patients with a questionable diagnosis of CF, NPD is very useful and is best at ruling out the diagnosis in the presence of a false positive sweat test.









Powered by Eventact EMS