Longitudinal circular photocurrent in Bi12SiO20 single crystals responds unexpectedly to external applied magnetic field in a Voigt configuration. The measured effect seems to defy phenomenological description for bulk photovoltaic effect in magnetic field. Magnetic field response across the visible spectrum, as well as for above band gap Eg ≈ 3.2 eV illumination all reveal much greater sensitivity to magnetic field for circularly polarized light when compared with linearly polarized light. While Faraday effect is well documented in Bi12SiO20, we present data that extend the wavelength and temperature range of existing magneto optic data. Peaks in the longitudinal (nonmagnetic) circular current with λ≈525 nm correspond with temperature independence of Verdet coefficient as measured in Bi12SiO20. The anomalous non-Hall response to magnetic field suggests that the observed magnetic field dependent behavior of the current results from magneto induced changes to the generation rate of spin polarized carriers excited from paramagnetic impurity centers. Work supported by the NSF and the U.S. Army Research Office.